Jan David Hauck
Language Under Construction
Bilingualism in Paraguay and Some Unsettled Thoughts About
Language
Berliner
Beiträge zur Ethnologie [ISSN 1610-6768], Bd. 19
Berlin, Dezember 2009, 169 Seiten; € 28,00; ISBN
978-3-89998-175-9
Über das Buch:
Language Under Construction tells two stories. One is about
the language Guaraní, the conflicts that have arisen
with its implementation in education, and the implications
that this has for a national identity politics. Guaraní
is an indigenous language that has achieved the status of
official language of Paraguay. Paraguay stands out among
South American countries because of its particular history
which has resulted in a relatively stable situation of bilingualism
of Spanish and Guaraní.
The second story is about the modernist construction of
language, i. e., language in the conceptual realm, and the
embedding of a politics of social inequality in this language
ideology. It unites a critical perspective on a formal view
of language and its roots in European Philosophy (Locke,
Herder) with a more general critique of the “deprovincialization”
(Chakrabarty) of Western scientific discourse. These two
issues converge in the analysis of the Boasian culture concept
that has been at the center of anthropo logical debates
in recent decades. They are employed here for a critical
perspective on the dominant language ideology of monoglot
standard as present in modern nation-states. The paradoxical
prominence of this ideology in a bilingual country like
Paraguay where it produces not one but two standards and
a negative perception of everyday communicative practices
alongside is the primary concern of this book.